When will Direct Line join the UK’s magic circle?

law firm

Regulatory changes in the UK legal market have allowed supermarket chain The Co-operative, haulage company Eddie Stobart and insurance provider Direct Line to adopt alternative business structures (ABSs) and offer legal services in a range of areas. Could these firms challenge the magic circle in pure revenue terms one day? Possibly.

If we assume that entry into the magic circle is broadly measured by revenue, then one brand that could potentially be a challenger is Direct Line, which claims to have around eight million policyholders. Its stated intention is to provide customers with legal advice on personal injury and non-injury claims, including debt recovery, employment and contract matters. But, imagine if it were to add legal services like conveyancing to its portfolio: it could then be knocking on the doors of the magic circle.

Consider this scenario. If we assume, on the back of the recovery in the housing market, that 15 per cent of Direct Line’s policyholders move home using its conveyancing services and are charged the average conveyancing fee, its annual fee income could reach circa £1bn. This would put Direct Line within spitting distance of the magic circle.

The larger firms would probably argue that these upstart legal service providers will have little impact on their revenues, as they do not tend to compete in the same areas of law. However, this might be a short-sighted view. Many of the larger ABS firms have brands that are known and trusted in the minds of potential clients. This presents a very real competitive threat to most law firms, which need to start responding if they are to survive and thrive.

Branding and voice

My friend and colleague Philip de Lisle was talking to the senior partner at a large law firm the other day about this very issue and he suggested that one of the biggest competitive challenges that the firm faced was that it did not have a voice in the wider market because its brand wasn’t known outside of legal circles.

Thus, in the face of increasing competition, law firms should be developing their brands and voice in the market. This does not mean that they should just commission a refresh of their logo, website, letterhead, marketing materials and business cards. They must go much further and understand that their brand is not just about a logo and tagline. It’s about following the four C’s: character, client experience, collateral and conversation.

  1. Character. What is the real character of a firm and how does that manifest itself in its culture, values, vision and mission? What a firm says it is and the reality need to be aligned.
  2. Client experience. Every law firm projecting an image of itself creates a brand promise. This has to be fulfilled by partners and employees at all levels on a day-to-day basis. Their actions, attitudes and the service they provide are the things that clients will remember and talk about.
  3. Collateral. The firm’s logo, website, letterhead, marketing materials and business cards are physical manifestations of the brand and convey its image and message. So, they must be aligned with the firm’s character and client experience.
  4. Conversation. A tremendous amount of time, effort and resources can be put into trying to create a strong brand. But, if all of these efforts fail to influence the conversation in the market, they will have been wasted. Ultimately, delighted and satisfied clients are the best source of new clients. Delivering anything less than that has the potential to do huge damage to new business development and the health of the brand.

Only those firms that are comfortable with and embrace change will weather the storm.


This post was originally published in the Feb 2014 issue of Managing Partner. You can check out the original here (beware it’s behind a paywall).


Photo Credit: nicksarebi via Compfight cc

Five ways to become more agile and responsive to your customers’ needs

About a month ago I wrote a piece called: Are You Sure Your Customers Will Wait Two Years For You To Change? The title and thrust of the piece was based on a conversation that I had had with Mark Lancaster, CEO of SDL, where he said: “When an executive team, in a large organisation, […]

Continue reading...

Customer experience requires a new type of responsive leader – Interview with Sid Banerjee of Clarabridge

Today’s interview is with Sid Banerjee, CEO of Clarabridge, a leader in the Customer Experience Management (CEM) space, particularly when it comes to helping firms mine their customer data to make better business decisions. Sid joins me today to talk about why he thinks industry, what firms can do to respond to the changes around […]

Continue reading...

Abandon email as a customer service channel at your peril

When it comes to customer service and the channels that businesses use to serve their customers, most of the talk in the marketplace is about self-service, smartphone apps, social media etc etc. All of which, I think, are really exciting and useful and these new channels are pushing the boundaries of how customers can get […]

Continue reading...

Everyone can create a ‘Genius Bar’ customer experience – Interview with Gary Ambrosino of Timetrade

Today’s interview is with Gary Ambrosino, President and COO of Timetrade. Gary joins me today to talk about the the work that they are doing helping a number of top banks in the USA transform their in-branch customer experience, how every retailer can now deliver a ‘Genius Bar’ experience and what retailers can do to […]

Continue reading...

The little things that destroy your customer experience

As a way of celebrating International Darwin Day on Feb 12th, MyCustomer.com published an article: Making a Charlie of themselves: The Darwin Awards for customer service. The article is pretty tongue-in-cheek but aims to showcase, in a light-hearted way, some of the biggest customer service failures of our time. Now, there is no doubt that […]

Continue reading...

Scaling up excellence is not a footprint problem but a mindset problem – Interview with Huggy Rao

Today’s interview is with Huggy Rao, Atholl McBean Professor of Organizational Behavior and Human Resources at Stanford Graduate School of Business and co-author of a new book, with Robert Sutton, called: Scaling Up Excellence: Getting to More Without Settling for Less. Huggy joins me today to talk about the book, the key scaling challenges that […]

Continue reading...

How NPS Correlates to Long-Term Revenue Growth


It’s been 10 years since Fred Reichheld first introduced Net Promoter Score (NPS) in his Harvard Business Review article “The One Number You Need to Grow.” Since then, thousands of companies have implemented NPS, including industry leaders like Apple, Intuit, Facebook, Southwest Airlines, and American Express. Now, with a ton of industry momentum, has NPS […]

Continue reading...

Transforming the internal customer service experience of your IT dept – Interview with Jason Andrew of BMC Software

Today’s interview is with Jason Andrew, the General Manager for EMEA at BMC Software. Jason joins me today to talk about MyIT, a new product that BMC have recently launched, and one that is set to transform how many large organisations function and the level of service and value that their IT departments deliver. This […]

Continue reading...