Could too much measurement be preventing the delivery of great customer service?

Tape measure

We are increasingly able to quantify and connect up our lives. We can now measure and monitor:

How many steps we have taken today.

Our average heart rate.

How well we have slept.

The temperature at home even when we are not there.

We can even ask our fridge to tell us whether we have run out of milk or when things are past their ‘use by’ dates.

Moreover, with the advent of the Internet of Things (IoT) where many, many more objects and devices will become ‘connected’ our ability to measure and monitor even more things is set to grow exponentially.

Now, many people are excited about the possibilities that this offers as it could and should allow us to make changes, pre-empt problems and make improvements in both our personal and business lives.

However, I often find myself wondering about how much measuring and monitoring is too much and if, like in The Observer Effect, all this data and measuring and monitoring has an impact on us and how we behave.

Given that, I was really interested to learn about a new study that was recently published in the Journal of Consumer Research called The Hidden Cost of Personal Quantification. It was conducted by Professor Jordan Etkin at Duke University who took a closer look at the impact of ‘personal measurement’.

Through a series of six experiments, Professor Etkin found that whilst measuring an activity can increase how much of it we do, at the same time it can it also reduce our enjoyment of that activity.

Professor Etkin, in the study, says that

“By drawing attention to output, measurement can make enjoyable activities feel more like work, which reduces their enjoyment. As a result, measurement can decrease continued engagement in the activity and subjective well-being.”

Now, whilst the experiments were only undertaken with a small group of American undergraduate students, they do raise some interesting questions about how and what we measure and the impact of that measurement.

But, what if we put aside the implications for the many consumer measurement applications that are out there and consider if the principle i.e. ‘measurement increases an activity but decreases engagement and well-being’ applies similarly to current management practices and how we manage and engage employees.

Moreover, if we monitor and measure too much in the workplace are we in danger of taking the engagement out of the work that people do? And, could that undermine what it takes to deliver great service?

Yes, more might get done because it is being measured. But, if the measurement of an activity also decreases engagement and well-being of employees then, surely, that should lead us to question the quality of the work that is being produced and whether it is as good as it can be.

What is clear is that whilst the study does not offer definitive proof of the impact of monitoring and measurement on human beings, it does raise some interesting questions about what we measure and the impact it could be having on the people we rely on to deliver the great service and experiences that we long to deliver. That in itself is worth thinking about.




This post was originally published on my column here.
Photo Credit: Andy Magee via Compfight cc

Proactive customer service drives retention, advocacy and growth – Interview with Monica Higgins of eSalon

Today’s interview is with Monica Higgins, eSalon‘s Director of Customer Service. eSalon is an award wining and rapidly growing company that provides salon quality, at-home hair color at affordable prices all online. Monica joins me today to talk customer service, what being proactive means for them and how they are providing salon level service and […]

Continue reading...

When it comes to employee engagement, what’s your keystone?

Recent research by Gallup found that only 32% of all employees in the US, only 17% in UK and, on average, only 13% of employees worldwide are really engaged with what they do at work. Those figures make for very sobering reading. But, what is even more sobering is the fact that, according to Gallup’s […]

Continue reading...

Delivering an excellent customer experience across 15 different countries – Interview with Delphine Mousseau of Zalando

Today’s interview is with Delphine Mousseau, VP Markets at the fashion online retailer, Zalando, a very successful ecommerce company based in Berlin that sells shoes, clothing and other fashion items in 15 different countries across Europe. Delphine joins me today to talk customer service, what that means for Zalando, how they are using that to […]

Continue reading...

Don’t leave the customer behind in your digital transformation journey

Research by McKinsey shows that over 70% of all transformation projects fail, which they define as “large-scale efforts to achieve substantial, sustainable changes in performance, enabled by long-term shifts in the mind-sets, behaviours, and capabilities of employees”. Their research also shows that the main reasons that transformation projects fail is that they, generally, under-invest in […]

Continue reading...

Having a great product without great support doesn’t mean anything – Interview with Sarah Metcalfe of SureFlap

Today’s interview is with Sarah Metcalfe, Head of Customer Service at SureFlap, an award winning smart pet products manufacturer based in the UK. Sarah joins me today to talk customer feedback and innovation, what good service looks like and what it means for SureFlap and why employee engagement is integral to that. This interview follows […]

Continue reading...

A story about the power of unconditional service guarantees

My wife and I recently returned from a trip to Havana, Cuba where we spent a few days on holiday. One evening during our trip, we found ourselves wandering around Old Havana looking for a place to go for dinner when we stumbled across a funky looking bar/restaurant called ‘Lamparilla Tapas Y Cerveza’. Now, we […]

Continue reading...

Employee engagement, real-time feedback and organisational indigestion – Interview with Cheryl Johnson of Echo Global Logistics

Today’s interview is with Cheryl Johnson, Head of HR for Echo Global Logistics. Cheryl joins me today to talk about what they are doing at Echo with regards implementing a real-time feedback system for their employees, why they are doing it, how it compliments their existing performance management systems and the results that they are […]

Continue reading...

Some people say that customer surveys are dead, they’re wrong and here’s why

I recently saw the headline of an article on called: The Deadzone: Why customer surveys are dead. Having a keen interest in customer service and experience, I was intrigued by the headline so I headed over to take a closer look. In the article, the Chief Marketing Officer of Clarabridge, Susan Ganeshan, argues that: […]

Continue reading...

How To WowMy New Book Is Out!

Looking to improve your customer experience? These 68 strategies will show you how to stand out from your competitors, whatever your business.

Don’t let your business fall behind, grab a copy of the book and take your customer experience to the next level.

Learn More!